High fertiliser costs adding £78m to farmers’ monthly bills as fresh food shortages continue
The high cost of fertiliser is linked to the high gas price as many fertilisers are made using gas as an ingredient or in the manufacturing process.
By George Smeeton
info@eciu.netShare
Last updated:
In the light of current fresh food shortages, new analysis from the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU) has found that the cost of fertiliser, pushed up during the gas crisis, has been adding around £78million a month to farmers’ bills.
The high cost of fertiliser is linked to the high gas price as many fertilisers are made using gas as an ingredient or in the manufacturing process. Some farmers have reportedly decided not to plant crops in part because of the high costs of fertiliser that would be required to grow them. [1]
Even though gas prices have fallen in the last few weeks they are still three times higher than before the crisis. Many analysts expect wholesale gas costs to remain higher than pre-crisis levels for several years, with potential for further volatility [2].
While fertiliser prices are also beginning to fall, they still remain at historically high levels: UK-produced ammonium nitrate was £234 per tonne in January 2020, reached a high of £841 per tonne in July 2022, and was still at £700 per tonne in January 2023.
Last year, academics conducted analysis for ECIU which found that 88% of food price inflation in 2022 was down to high oil and gas prices and the impacts of climate change, equivalent to adding £407 to the average household’s food bill.
Recent reports suggest there is now a shortage of leaks due to the impacts of last year’s extreme weather [3]. The heatwave in the UK saw temperatures rise to a record 40.3C and was followed by a widespread drought which still continues in parts of the South West and East Anglia, according to the Environment Agency. British potato crops were also hit by the drought. [4]
Matt Williams, land use analyst for the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit, said: “Farmers are getting hit from all sides, but underlying many of their troubles are oil and gas. A high gas price made heating greenhouses unaffordable, it’s made fertiliser expensive and burning these fossil fuels has driven up extreme weather like the droughts that are still ongoing in parts of the country.
“Investing in electric heat pumps for greenhouses, solar and wind on farms and British-made low-carbon fertilisers are, in hindsight, steps that might have helped us through the current storm. These measures plus building farms’ resilience through planting trees to shade livestock and trap moisture in soils would help boost the UK’s long-term food security.”
The analysis looked at three commonly used fertilisers (Ammonium Nitrate, Urea, and Liquid Urea Ammonium Nitrate). In 2023 British farmers could spend as much as £938million extra due to the increased cost of these fertilisers, equivalent to £78million a month.
Tesco has recently launched a programme to support farmers to trial alternatives to gas-based fertilisers. [5]
Pawel Kisielewski, CEO of CCm Technologies, a British company developing low-carbon fertiliser, said “The UK has entered into a food and energy crisis, damaging both consumers and farmers. We don’t need to be in this situation, as the UK looks to meet net zero targets it must prioritise the acceleration of UK based fertiliser products that are de-linked from international gas prices and reduce 30% of global greenhouse gas emissions associated with traditional fossil fuel-based fertiliser.”
Robert Shaw, UK Director at N2 Applied, a company developing plasma-based emissions-free fertiliser technology, said: “Farmers across the UK have been having to bear the brunt of soaring chemical fertiliser prices over the past year or more, and are under constant pressure to have to pass at least some of that cost further up the supply chain to retailers, and ultimately to consumers. The increases are so substantial that a direct impact on the cost of many food products has been inevitable. The UK needs to accelerate the adoption of more sustainable fertilisers that don’t rely on chemical inputs to increase the country’s food security and counter price rises where that’s possible.”
Wyn Morgan, Honourary Professor at the University of Sheffield (and one of the authors of the food inflation analysis mentioned above), commenting on the food prices increases said: “A key driver is the underlying costs of production of raw agricultural products, those that then go through processing to reach consumers. Within this the influence of energy is critical. Rising energy costs not only affect farmers directly - through diesel use for machinery or heating greenhouses - but also indirectly through fertiliser use. Energy is a major component of fertliser production and as energy costs rise, particularly gas, then the costs of fertilisers rise too putting pressure on farm costs. When supply chain costs increase arising from higher energy costs (processing and transport uses a lot of energy) then there is bound to be upward pressure on the prices consumers pay.”
Notes to editors:
1. The real impact of cost pressures on the horticulture sector: https://www.nfuonline.com/updates-and-information/promar-report-the-real-impact-of-cost-pressures-on-the-horticulture-sector/
2. See, for example, data in gas forward curve showing elevated prices (compared to c.50p/therm pre-crisis) and commentary discussing potential sources of volatility. (Businesswise Solutions, accessed 27 February 2023): https://www.businesswisesolutions.co.uk/energy-market-snapshot/
3. Food shortages: British leek supplies 'exhausted by April' in latest warning: https://news.sky.com/story/food-shortages-british-leek-supplies-exhausted-by-april-in-latest-warning-12818739
4. Too parched for potatoes if irrigation not available: https://www.thescottishfarmer.co.uk/news/23044488.parched-potatoes-irrigation-not-available/
5. Tesco launches UK’s largest low-carbon fertiliser roll-out to increase food security and cut the carbon footprint of its veg: https://www.tescoplc.com/news/2023/greener-greens-tesco-launches-uk-s-largest-low-carbon-fertiliser-roll-out-to-increase-food-security-and-cut-the-carbon-footprint-of-its-veg/
Analysis:
The analysis updates ECIU calculations made in January to include an extra fertiliser product (Liquid Urea Ammonium Nitrate), use current prices and a slightly refined methodology.
Data Sources
British Survey Fertiliser Practice 2020 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1094276/fertiliseruse-annualreport2020-28jul22.pdf
British Survey Fertiliser Practice 2021 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1094283/fertiliseruse-annualreport2021-28jul22.pdf
(Table GB3.2 in both documents)
Fertiliser Prices AHDB https://ahdb.org.uk/GB-fertiliser-prices
Calculations
Ammonium Nitrate
2020 use 1,307,000 tonnes
2021 use (most recent year) 1,363,000 tonnes (assume 2023 use is same as 2021 use)
2020 average price across AN UK and AN Imported: £216.9
2023 (average price across AN UK and AN Imported) assumed price for 12 months based on January 2023: £691
2020 total spend by farmers = 1,307,000 x 216.9 = £283,488,300
2023 total spend by farmers = 1,363,000 x 691 = £941,833,000
Extra Ammonium Nitrate bill 2023 = £658,344,700
Urea
2020 use 205,000 tonnes
2021 use (most recent year) 213,000 tonnes (assume 2023 use is same as 2021 use)
2020 average price Urea: £250.8
2023 assumed price for 12 months based on January 2023: £582
2020 total spend by farmers = 205,000 x 250.8 = £51,414,000
2023 total spend by farmers = 213,000 x 582 = £123,966,000
Extra Urea bill 2023 = 72,552,000
Liquid Urea Ammonium Nitrate
2020 use 469,000 tonnes
2021 use (most recent year) 492,000 tonnes (assume 2023 use is same as 2021 use)
2020 average price (based on single data point for October 2020): £192
2023 assumed price for 12 months based on January 2023: £605
2020 total spend by farmers = 469,000 x 192 = £90,048,000
2023 total spend by farmers = 492,000 x 605 = £297,660,000
Extra Liquid Urea Ammonium Nitrate bill = £207,612,000
Total extra bill for fertilisers in 2023 for British farmers = £938,508,700
For more information:
George Smeeton, Head of Communications, ECIU, Tel: 07894 571 153, email: george.smeeton@eciu.net