Comment: Transport Secretary calls rumoured Westminster EV slowdown ‘wholly unacceptable’

Going slow on EVs could result in 10% more emissions at the point when Scotland’s climate plan would otherwise be getting the nation to net zero

Profile picture of Izzy Romilly

By Izzy Romilly

info@eciu.net

Last updated:

Scottish Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn has said it would be “wholly unacceptable” for UK-wide EV sales targets to be weakened without sufficient consultation with devolved governments [1], noting also a recently published letter from the UK Climate Change Committee which stated that “the Zev mandate is working effectively” and “current trajectories should be maintained” [2].

A plausible worst-case scenario for watering down the UK’s Zero Emissions Vehicle (ZEV) Mandate could lead to 7.5 million tonnes of extra greenhouse gas emissions in Scotland by 2050, according to analysis from the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit [3]. 

Laura Anderson, senior associate at the ECIU said: 

“The Scottish Government clearly doesn’t want to accept any watering down of EV sales targets from Westminster, citing both climate change and cost of living concerns. 

“Any rollback could add millions of tonnes of carbon to Scotland’s total, making it harder to reach net zero emissions, which we know scientifically is the only way the world can stop ever-worsening climate change. 

“With increasing pump prices, electric cars are protecting more and more families’ finances, but cutting EV sales targets would in turn cut competition between car manufacturers, limiting choice. This would also mean limiting the pool of second-hand EVs in years to come, the demand for which is understandably surging. 

“There’s also knock-on implications for jobs with any slowdown creating unwanted uncertainty for Scottish charging companies.” 

UK Ministers reportedly met last week [4] to discuss relaxing the 2030 sales target, with the rumoured preference being a change from 80% to 60% of all cars sold in 2030 being EVs and extended flexibilities. This would create a steeper trajectory to reach 100% EV sales in 2035, and would therefore be likely to result in parts of the industry pushing for further weakening or extensions to sales targets at later points.

The plausible worst-case scenario of the final target being pushed back to 2040 could result in 7.5 million additional tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, which would make Holyrood’s job of meeting Scottish carbon targets much harder.  Data from the UK’s Department for Transport suggests that the impacts could be even higher, and similar changes to the ZEV Mandate for vans would add further emissions. 

The Scottish Government has committed to achieving net zero emissions throughout all sectors of its economy by 2045 [5]. However, the rumoured weakening of the UK’s ZEV Mandate, which UK Ministers reportedly discussed last week, would see manufacturers facing lesser incentives to bring their best range of low-cost EVs to Scottish customers, hampering the pace of EV uptake, jeopardising Scotland’s emissions trajectory, and locking in higher prices for drivers.  

Dr Simon Cran-McGreehin, Head of Analysis at ECIU, said: 

“Not only did the Scottish Government draft elements of its net zero plan based on these rules, parts of the car-making industry and growing EV charging businesses did too. Policies like EV sales targets are supposed to be long-term and free from changes so businesses and governments alike can make plans and investment decisions.

"A weakening would likely mean Scottish drivers missing out on the same choice of low-cost EVs as drivers elsewhere in the world, while creating millions more tonnes of greenhouse gases that the Scottish government – and our climate – had not budgeted for.” 

Changes to most parts of the ZEV Mandate require agreement between the UK Government and the devolved administrations. Parts 1 to 4 of the consultation are conducted jointly by the UK government, Scottish Government, Welsh Government, and the Department for Infrastructure in Northern Ireland. [6]

Only Part 5 is fully within the gift of the UK Government, namely options for defining the phase-out by 2030 of sales of new internal combustion engines cars.  There is also a ZEV Mandate for vans, and any further changes to that policy would add to Scotland’s emissions. 

ENDS

 

Notes to editors:
 

  1. The Standard, ‘Watering down EV mandate would be ‘wholly unacceptable’, says Stephen Flynn’, 18th November 2026 
  2. Climate Change Committee, 18th November 2026 https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/letter-nigel-topping-cmg-to-the-rt-hon-heidi-alexander-mp-secretary-of-state-for-transport-on-the-zero-emission-vehicle-zev-mandate-review/  
  3. See methodology below 
  4. The Times, ‘Labour cabinet split over plans to water down EV sales targets’, 19th November 2026 
  5. The CCC advised on Scotland’s carbon budgets out to 2045 (Scotland's Carbon Budgets (CCC, May 2025)), and these were accepted into law by a vote in the Scottish Parliament: The Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 (Scottish Carbon Budgets) Amendment Regulations 2025)i 
  6. Deprtment for Transport, Zero emission vehicle mandate review (DfT, 2026) 

Methodology 

Analysis of emissions impacts of changing the ZEV Mandate has been conducted by the UK Department for Transport (DfT) (see Table on p77 of Zero emission vehicle mandate review (DfT, 14 Aug 2026)) cited by the CCC (Letter re. ZEV Mandate Review (CCC, 18 Nov 2026)) presented cars and vans separately.  DfT’s consultation does not contain results for what is now thought to be the UK Government’s current preference (60% car target for 2030, similar cuts for vans, with extended flexibilities), but ECIU analysis of various scenarios suggests that this would be similar to Option 3 in DfT’s consultation (50% car target for 2030, and 40% for vans) which was therefore used as a proxy for the rumoured preferred changes. 

The ECIU analysis considered potential weakening of the ZEV Mandate for cars, and did not include similar changes being considered for vans, which would add more emissions.  The analysis was based on the methodology used for this earlier analysis: Looming EV policy U-turn could result in more than half of Rosebank’s emissions (ECIU, Oct 2026).  The analysis was updated in two ways.  Firstly, sales of EVs were modelled to reflect the rumoured preference by the UK Government, i.e. to reduce the 2030 car target from 80% and 60%, to make similar cuts to the 2030 van target, and to extend flexibilities.  Extending flexibilities was modelled as the inclusion of efficiency gains of new PHEVs and ICEs out to 2034, instead of to 2029 as under the current policy.   Secondly, the extra GHG emissions from having more ICEs and PHEVs were split into devolved administrations based on their shares of UK new car sales over the past decade, using data from Table VEH1154 (DfT, 2026).  The results for Scotland were compared with its carbon budgets, that were recommended by the CCC and approved by the Scottish Parliament last year.   

Based on the rumoured preference, Scotland’s emissions from cars could be 4.2 Mt higher from 2027 to 2050, of which 1.2 Mt could occur during Scotland’s 4th carbon budget (2041–2045), amounting to 5% of that budget total.  Estimates of UK-wide emissions in the consultation by the UK Department for Transport imply higher impacts, equating to 6% of Scotland’s 4th carbon budget. 

These changes would create a steeper trajectory to 100% new EV sales in 2035, such that the industry would be likely to call for further changes in future.  To illustrate this possible ‘domino effect’, the modelling was updated with the 100% target pushed back to 2040, which is considered to be a plausible worst-case scenario.  This could increase Scotland’s extra emissions by 2050 to 7.5 Mt, and could double the extra emissions during Scotland’s 4th carbon budget to 2.4 Mt, 10% of the budget, just as the country is set to hit net zero emissions.  Again, estimates from the UK’s Department for Transport would give an even higher impact (but lack of detail about that methodology means that extending it to the modelled worst-case is more speculative), as including any weakening of the targets for vans would also add emissions. 

Sensitivity analysis was conducted (e.g. extending flexibilities to 2032 rather than 2034), giving similar results.  The extra emissions due to potential changes to the ZEV Mandate come on top of the (smaller) impacts that will be caused by previous changes to the policy, and on top of any differences between earlier policies and the EV sales trajectory used in the CCC’s analysis.