Comment: UK-EU ETS Linkage

A comment on the expected announcement that the UK and the EU are set to link their emissions trading schemes (ETS's)

Profile picture of Tom Cantillon

By Tom Cantillon

info@eciu.net

Last updated:

Tom Cantillon, Senior Analyst at the Energy and Climate intelligence Unit (ECIU) said, 

"A range of industry associations support linking our carbon market with the EU’s, because it will strengthen and stabilise the market [1]. Strong carbon markets are vital if we want to futureproof our industries and protect them from losing out to cheaper, dirtier competitors. Not only that, linking the systems will improve market access for our exports to the EU, as products like steel and electricity will no longer face an EU carbon border tariff. This means all the revenue from carbon pricing will stay in the UK, to be spent by governments here, instead of those taxes ending up in EU coffers [2]. 

“Combined with the UK’s carbon border tariff to be introduced in January [3], this move will also protect UK industries from being undercut by cheap, dirty imports that come from outside the EU, such as Chinese steel.  

“Emissions trading schemes are increasingly the norm – with 30% of global emissions covered by a carbon price of some kind, and established schemes in countries like Canada, South Korea, China, South Africa and Vietnam [4]. When you poll the public, they overwhelmingly back the principle of making high-polluting industries pay tax on the emissions they produce – carbon markets and border tariffs uphold that principle, while financially incentivising companies to reduce their emissions over time [5].” 
 

Explainer: ETS, CBAM and fertiliser 

ETS linkage has long been supported by industry associations like Energy UK, UK Steel and the Mineral Products Association, on the basis that it will lead to a larger more liquid carbon market, reduce price instability, and boost investor confidence. They also see it benefitting business via reduced transaction and administrative costs. Coupled with a well-functioning UK CBAM, it is seen as a means to protect British industry from carbon dumping while supporting decarbonisation. Analysts have also suggested that linkage will lead to lower carbon prices in the long-term versus an unlinked scenario, potentially 40% higher by the early 2030s.  

Energy costs are often discussed in the context of Britian’s industrial competitiveness, driven largely by gas prices, as industry is mostly exempt from policy and network costs. A specific debate in this context is the impact of ETS and CBAM on UK fertiliser, with concerns raise that these have a negative impact on UK farmers via increased fertiliser costs. The evidence suggests that this will not be the case, if it does occur, for several years. This is for three primary reasons: 

Gas sets the price of fertiliser. Ammonium nitrate (AN), the UK’s main nitrogen fertiliser, is made from natural gas. ECIU analysis of AHDB fertiliser price data [6] and UK gas prices shows that the gas price has been on average more than a quarter of fertilisers’ price since 2017, and around three-fifths at the height of the energy crisis.  

The UK CBAM adds little to cost in the short term. When the UK CBAM enters into force in 2027, it will add an estimated £4 per tonne for non-EU imported AN against a price of £470/t for AN. That is equivalent to an ordinary month’s fluctuation in fertiliser prices, or the effect on production costs of a normal, single-day move in the gas price [7]. 

Most of our fertiliser comes from Europe, and linkage exempts it. Around three-fifths of the UK’s nitrogen fertiliser imports come from the EU, and virtually all imported AN [8]. With linked carbon markets, the groundwork is laid for an exemption of these imports from UK CBAM, meaning their cost-impact is avoided.   

CBAM levies are expected to rise year-on-year as free allocation of allowances are phased out. This is set out years in advance and can be planned for. The primary risk to farmers’ fertiliser bill is another gas price spike. Nitrogen fertiliser prices roughly tripled during the gas crisis and remain around double pre-crisis levels [9]. 

ENDS
 

Notes to editors:
 

[1] See statements from Energy UK, UK Steel and the Mineral Products Association 

[2] https://www.frontier-economics.com/media/fi4i4b2o/frontier-linking-uk-eu-carbon-markets-final-report.pdf 

[3] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism-cbam-policy-summary/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism-cbam-policy-summary 

[4] https://carbonpricingdashboard.worldbank.org 

[5] https://climatebarometer.org/as-climate-impacts-intensify-who-should-pay-for-the-costs/ 

[6] https://ahdb.org.uk/GB-fertiliser-prices 

[7] HMRC’s illustrative 2027 CBAM levy for fertiliser is £1.45/tCO2e. Applied to the EU’s default value for imported AN (2.0-2.7 tCO2e/t) this is around £3-4/t. The median monthly price swing for imported fertiliser, over the past two years based on AHDB data, is roughly £6/t. Making a tonne of ammonium nitrate uses about 13 GJ of gas, roughly 127 therms. So every 1p/therm change in the gas price changes the cost of a tonne by about £1.30, and 10p/therm by about £13. On that basis, the £3–4/t carbon border charge is equivalent to a move of about 2.5–3p/therm in the daily gas price, a swing regularly experienced in the market. 

[8] Based on UK Trade Data of fertiliser commodities in-scope for UK CBAM.  

[9] Based on AHDB fertiliser price data: AN (UK/imported) 3.5/3.8x during gas crisis, now 2.0/2.1x; Urea 3.4x at peak, now 1.8x; UAN 3.3x at peak now 1.9x; DAP/TSP 3.2x at peak now 2.2x