Steel on the Border: Trade exposure and the implications of UK and EU CBAM for UK Steel

UK steel set to gain from EU carbon market link, but UK border rules lag EU

Last updated:

Linking the UK and EU emissions trading scheme (ETS) will benefit the UK steel industry, according to a new report commissioned by the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU) drawing on analysis provided by the independent consultancy CBI Economics. The report is released today as leaders gather in Brussels for the EU-UK summit.

Chapter 1: The UK's steel trade exposure

  • The UK steel trade deficit reached a record £2.6 billion in 2024, driven by a fall of around two thirds in domestic crude steel output between 2014 and 2024. By 2025, output had fallen by more than three quarters from its 2014 level. The domestic supply share of total consumption stands at approximately 30%, against the government's initial aim of returning to 40 to 50%.
  • UK steel trade is heavily concentrated on the EU, 67% of exports and 66% of imports by value in 2024. The bilateral UK–EU regulatory relationship is the single most consequential variable for the sector's competitive position.
  • The UK generates 10 to 11 million tonnes of ferrous scrap annually but consumes less than 25% domestically. The surplus is exported principally to Turkey, creating industrial value leakage as the UK exports raw material and re-imports finished steel.
  • As the EAF transition accelerates, domestic demand for high-quality, low-copper scrap will rise substantially. Realising that potential requires coordinated reform across vehicle end-of-life regulation and scrap processing standards.

Chapter 2: Understanding UK steel trade dynamics

  • Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanisms (CBAMs) are designed to address carbon leakage by applying a comparable carbon price to imports of emissions-intensive goods. UK industry has broadly supported a CBAM as a way of ensuring that domestic producers are not undercut by higher-carbon imports from countries without equivalent carbon pricing. Gareth Stace, Director General of UK Steel, argued in 2023 that "the vast majority of the world's steel producers face no carbon costs… we need a level playing field where imported and domestically produced steel face similar carbon costs, and a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism can deliver just that."
  • The UK CBAM comes into force on 1 January 2027, applying a levy on embodied carbon in imported steel and four other sectors. Liability is calculated as embodied emissions multiplied by the CBAM rate (calculated and published quarterly by the government from the previous quarter's average UK ETS auction price, adjusted for free allocation), minus any Carbon Price Relief for carbon costs already paid overseas.
  • The most consequential design difference is the treatment of default emission values. HMRC's published UK defaults are set by product but apply regardless of country of origin until 2029, and the UK rate deducts free allocation at the sector average. At HMRC's illustrative rate, a tonne of hot-rolled coil imported on default values would face a UK CBAM charge of roughly £26 to £37, against a net EU CBAM cost of around €179 for Chinese hot-rolled coil imported in 2026. UK Steel estimates the UK ETS cost for a UK blast furnace producer at around £61 per tonne in 2027.4
  • A concluded UK–EU ETS link would trigger mutual CBAM exemptions, removing the EU carbon border charge from approximately £3 billion of annual UK steel exports to the EU, and the UK CBAM charge from EU goods imported into the UK. Linkage would not by itself change UK default values for imports from third countries.
  • Formal ETS linkage negotiations began in January 2026 following the May 2025 Leaders' Summit Common Understanding. In October 2026 negotiators were reported to have reached agreement on the ETS file, although no agreement has been published, and the next UK-EU Summit is expected to be held in Brussels on 20 November 2026. Until linkage is in force, UK exporters face EU CBAM compliance obligations that the UK government has estimated could cost UK industry around £800 million a year, and the UK domestic market remains more exposed to carbon- intensive imports than its EU counterpart.
  • US tariffs present a mixed picture for UK steel trade. UK-origin steel retains a preferential 25% Section 232 tariff rate following the US-UK Economic Prosperity Deal of May 2025, while imports from most other origins face 50%, providing a meaningful competitive advantage for UK producers in the US market. However, qualifying for the preferential rate requires steel to have been melted and poured in the UK, and the US market remains a smaller destination for UK exports than the EU.