Families in new builds saddled with extra £6,000 energy bill

Homes built since new build warm home standards for insulation were first axed in 2016 have together been left with an additional £5 billion energy bill

Profile picture of Jess Ralston

By Jess Ralston

info@eciu.net

Last updated:

A series of successive Governments’ delays to new build standards have resulted in families living in new build homes paying an extra £5 billion in energy bills between 2017 and 2025, new analysis from the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit (ECIU) has found [1]. 

The Zero Carbon Homes standard was scrapped in 2016 following housebuilder lobbying [2], and then its replacement the Future Homes Standard is facing delays in Whitehall [3]. This has resulted in around 1.35 million new homes in England being built to lower standards of insulation between 2016 and 2024. These homes have cumulatively faced an extra £5 billion in energy bills because of lower insulation requirements, and a lack of heat pumps and solar panels. The extra cost will have been even higher if new homes have not met standards in practice.

If the current Government does not implement the already delayed Future Homes Standard in 2025, there is a risk that more new homes are built to lower insulation standards and without solar panels, forcing occupants to pay higher bills when they live in their new home.

Baroness Joanna Penn, Conservative Peer and former Treasury and Housing and Local Government Minister, said:

The Future Homes Standard needs to be implemented without any further delay. The longer the government waits the greater the missed opportunity to build more energy efficient homes - saving customers money on their energy bills. Pioneering housebuilders have shown it can be done – the government now needs to get on with it.”

Jess Ralston, Energy Analyst at the ECIU, said “Governments giving into house builder lobbying has left Britain with more poor quality homes, more dependent on foreign gas and more exposed to the highly volatile gas markets during the ongoing energy crisis. Unless we lower our gas demand by building better, warmer homes that run on electric heat pumps then we’ll just have to import more from abroad as the North Sea continues its decades-long decline in output. Establishing UK supply chains to build these high quality homes would create skilled jobs and growth.” 

Different standards for new builds were due to come in at different times. Homes built in 2016 in line with practices of the time – which were worse than the required standards [4] – will have spent an extra £1,000 on gas on average by the end of 2025 because of the scrapping of the basic Zero Carbon Homes standard for insulation. They will also have spent an extra £1,100 due to having a gas boiler rather than an electric heat pump, and an extra £3,900 on electricity from not having solar panels fitted, meaning they paid £6,000 extra on energy bills in 2017-2025. 

Homes built in 2019, which would have seen further uplifts to insulation under an advanced Zero Carbon Homes standard, have spent an extra £1,400 on gas on average between 2020 to 2025 due to lower levels of insulation, £750 extra due to not having a heat pump, and nearly £3,000 extra on electricity because of not having solar panels. Therefore, the total extra bills for homes built in 2019 reach £5,150.  

And homes built in 2022, despite being built to slightly tighter 2021 Building Regulations – and assuming that those standards were actually met – have still spent an extra £450 on gas on average because these 2021 standards for insulation were more lax than those due to come in from 2019, and almost as much again due to not having a heat pump. Extra electricity bills because of a lack of solar adds around £1,750 to bills, taking total extra energy bills to over £2,600. 

The Future Homes Standard, delayed from 2023 to 2025 under the Johnson Government [5], would see tighter insulation standards, and typically heat pumps and solar panels fitted to new builds, although housebuilders can meet the standard using a variety of technologies. 

The current Government is yet to publish the technical specification despite the supposed 2025 implementation date and there have been delays in Whitehall to the development of the Home Energy Model, which is used to calculate whether new homes would meet the standard [6].

This means that a 2025 date for implementation is increasingly unlikely, despite the near decade of delay, and the implications for energy independence if new builds are more reliant on gas. 

The Government’s Impact Assessment for the 2016 Zero Carbon Homes standard [7] found “additional costs of zero-carbon homes will be largely passed back to land-owners in reduced land value uplift”, rather than increasing new build sales prices. 


Notes to editors:

1. Methodology: The analysis compared the heat demand for new-build homes with an average area of c.75m2, using estimates for the heat demand per m2 under different regimes.  The 2013 Standard required about 55 kWh/m2 per year, although typical practice gave c.64 kWh/m2 per year; the ZCH Basic standard would have equated to just over 40 kWh/m2 per year for new homes built from the start of 2016; the ZCH Advanced standard would have equated to c.25 kWh/m2 per year for new homes built from the start of 2019, as would the FHS for new homes built from mid-2025 (assumed); and the 2021 Uplift equates to c.45 kWh/m2 per year for new homes built from the mid-2022.

These levels of heat demand were translated into gas demand using a typical boiler efficiency of 85%, and into electrical demand using an achievable new-build heat pump COP of 4.0 (which is achievable in new homes).  Costs per year were calculated using Ofgem’s price cap data for gas standing charges, gas unit rates, and electricity unit rates.  Costs cited are total costs, which have mostly been paid by the households, but partly by Government via the ‘price guarantee’ in 2022 and 2023.  The rate of home-building was taken as the average over the period i.e. c.150,000 per year, with this annual figure split in half when building standards changed partway through a year.

For solar, a typical home is considered to use 50% of solar generated power and export the other 50%, at the average Smart Export Guarantee tariff of 25% of import unit rates, which in turn were taken from Ofgem’s price cap (weighted by demand in each quarter of the year).  Household electricity demand was taken to be the median value for EPC band B;  in practice, households with heat pumps and hence higher electricity demand could make use of a higher proportion of their solar power generation, so the results are likely to be underestimates.

2. OpenDemocracy, 2023: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/new-build-homes-gas-boilers-heat-pumps-developers-lobby-government/ and Unearthed investigation, 2021: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/jul/05/housebuilder-taylor-wimpey-opposed-plans-cut-new-home-emissions 

3. The Guardian, 2024: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/oct/16/act-now-on-best-green-credentials-for-new-homes-in-england-ministers-urged

4. On average, new homes require more energy for heating than expected under the building standards in force at the time.  This analysis assumes (perhaps generously) that homes built since mid-2022 actually meet the standards of the 2021 Uplift.

5. BBC, 2020: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-55020558

6. Housing Today, 2024: https://www.housingtoday.co.uk/news/concern-at-software-failure-as-government-delays-green-homes-consultation/5128226.article

7. HM Government, 2011: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/zero-carbon-homes-impact-assessment 

For more information or for interview requests:

George Smeeton, Head of Communications, ECIU, Tel: 07894 571 153, email: george.smeeton@eciu.net